I'm excited to go home, but a part of me will always be here with the people I've come to love over my short stay here. I'll miss them all - particularly this one.
Monday, July 30, 2007
Peluqueria
I'm excited to go home, but a part of me will always be here with the people I've come to love over my short stay here. I'll miss them all - particularly this one.
Friday, July 20, 2007
Los Seres Humanos
Arana has been a point of contention amongst the Grameen Bank operators since the inception of the new center. In physical distance, it is only a few blocks and two bus rides away. However, it couldn’t be further away in emotional and mental distance.
Arana was not always as rural and still as it is now. The abandoned offices were once milling with people. Factories turned profits and trains sped by on their ways to all-important destinations. But Argentina is a vibrant and dynamic country. Arana couldn’t have expected it to stay still forever. But when Argentina’s political and economic climates changed drastically, the factories failed to adjust.
The now closed and abandoned shell of a factory now stands as an ominous portent of the risks of failing to progress. Yet, the people who occupy the area fail to heed it; they are quick to close their hearts and minds at the first sign of change or trouble and are slow to explore and discuss possible solutions. Yet, oddly enough, all of this town that is so set in its ways closes for the formal presentation of the presidential candidate, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, the wife of current President Néstor Kirchner, who is attempting to ride on the coattails of the much loved Eva Perón. Aside from having been Argentina’s First Lady at one point in time, the two couldn’t be any more different. Fernández lacks the heart for the humble that was the driving force behind Evita, her benevolence, and her popularity. Yet it was precisely for this announcement that all of the humble community of Arana, its schools, and businesses closed.
It is undoubtedly an estranged area. However, the people in it are still los seres humanos, and in this commonality we find the ability to relate to them, commiserating with them in their difficulties, and rejoicing in their successes. It’s an odd thing, this commonality that transcends not only city lines, but social classes, religious sects, and political lines, as well. And sometimes, for one to be able to interact on a meaningful level with those who appear to be the others, one must only see and respect this commonality. Most of the time, this respect is all “they” want and need.
Friday, July 13, 2007
Cultural Immersion
I found the experience riveting, beginning with the smoke-filled hallways and waiting rooms. In exchange for my first and last name, and age, I was immediately admitted into the emergency room. After a short wait, a young doctor clad in street clothing knelt down, proceeded to poke my ankle, look at my wincing face, and promptly declare the ligament to be torn, prescribing me painkillers without a single question regarding my medical history. House would've loved the medical system here. :) And then I was out the door. No insurance, no fees, and no forms. Just a "ciao."
Saturday, July 7, 2007
Dinner at Roberto's
Dinner at Roberto's was a great glimpse into an Argentine family. The level of affection that pervades Argentine culture is perhaps most starkly seen in the kisses with which they all greet each other here. This affection is even stronger within the household, between siblings, and parents and their children.
In stark contrast to the image of a stately or reserved father, Roberto, a former film director created a photo montage for Violeta, appropriately set to the song Pompilla. Immanuel has an extremely close relationship with Mariaemma, his mom, with whom he shares every detail of his day as soon as he gets home. Rather than shrug off hugs and feign a macho demeanor as many of the teenage boys his age do, he openly hugs and kisses his little brothers, and speaks with respect of Violeta and Juan.
Roberto and Mariaemma have given their children the freedom to choose nearly everything for themselves. Perhaps it was because they were such strong models of honesty, solidarity, humility, and moral upstanding themselves, that the children given such free reign, chose to become such strong and wise people. Undoubtedly, the openly expressed unconditional love that the parents showed them helped make them into the confident people that they are today.
Microfinance
This focus on improving the lives of borrowers holistically gives microfinance its strength in an emotional and personal aspect, but it is also a significant weakness when it comes to intellectual or financial senses, because oftentimes, this focus on solidarity and trust inhibits the bank from doing the financially sound thing.
And this polar contrast is perhaps perfectly exhibited by Oscar and Anna. Thursday, July 5 marked the grand opening of a new Grameen center in Arana. But it has been a topic of contention for quite some time between the individuals at the bank with different ideologies. Anna questions the bank’s new presence in Arana. It is a crudely constructed neighborhood that has arisen from the remains of an abandoned oil factory. On any given day, you’ll see more cows, horses, and stray dogs than you will see people. Yes, the potential market is too small. Yes, there isn’t enough potential for diversity to avoid competition between the borrowers. Yes, managing risk will be a challenging if not impossible task. Yes, it is inefficient to stretch the bank’s resources out to reach such an isolated area. Yes. Yes. Yes. But the need is there, and that is why they must go, Oscar says – the poorer the borrowers, the better.
As its name entails, microfinance is still concerned with finance. And risk management is undoubtedly a key concern here with these high risk-profile borrowers. It is just that oftentimes, personal and emotional concerns trump financial soundness. And so Grameen has a 94% repayment rate excluding interest, and is still not self-sustainable. How can we find a balance?
Abandoned railroad station, now a home.
Ramona, a former borrower, now a new group leader with Grameen
